The Trifold Cargo Liner is the same with and without the spare. The Cargo Tray that goes in the well is different if you have a spare.. Part # PT-206-08216 with no spare and PT-206-08217 with a spare. The jack is stored in the well. One of the pictures above has an arrow pointing to the location of the jack.Great info everyone. I think for me, the confusion is not with the trifold since it fits whether or not you have a spare.....The confusion seems to be with the cargo tray in the very rear of the vehicle which would be behind the third row seats and used if they are in a upward position. If you are looking at how the tray liner fits on the spare tire side for vehicles that come with a spare tire it fits fine. However, if the vehicle doesn't come with a spare tire (and only the repair kit), then there is no jack compartment on the right hand side and therefore the floor liner is a different cut on the right hand side. And that is where the misfit is if you order a mat for a vehicle that has a spare and it really doesn't. Make sense? Correct me if I am wrong. Thanks to all.