Toyota Sienna Forum - siennachat.com banner

Timing belt/water pump change on '05 CE with 65k miles?

6.2K views 6 replies 5 participants last post by  jlyang  
#1 ·
Hi all,
I have an '05 Sienna CE that was manufactured in August 2005.

It's driven 8-10k miles yearly and I'm aware the manufacturer's timing belt interval is 6 years/90k, and am aware that the failure rate within 6 years/90k is probably close to zero.

Anyways, I asked a trustworthy local garage re. replacing the timing belt/water pump; they are fine with my supplying my own parts, and they would charge $429 labor + $60 for Toyota coolant, and they recommend changing the timing belt/water pump/seals/tensioner/etc. at the same time, included in the $429 labor charge. The shop has an excellent reputation and I don't think they're attempting to do extra work to upcharge.
$400 gets a Toyota dealer-supplied OEM kit from Ebay like
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Toyota-V6-T.../300740813075?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&hash=item46058ca113&vxp=mtr
There are cheaper kits too, but if I'm supplying my own parts to the shop, would feel safer using all Toyota-branded parts.

What do you all think? Reasonable to proceed vs. wait a year or two? Am guessing it's highly unlikely the original belt will fail in the next 1-2 years. On the other hand, it is an interference engine, it would not be good if the wife/kids were stranded somewhere, and if I did the job now I would not touch the timing belt/water pump until the year 2020, by which point the vehicle may not be running anyways, so delaying the job 1-2 years may not save any money.

Also, would you change the spark plugs at the same time you are changing the timing belt?

Appreciate your thoughts!
 
#2 ·
Just a heads-up: it you supply your own parts, then the mechanic usually won't back them if there is a failure.

I planned to replace the CV joints on a vehicle, but didn't have the right tools. So, I brought the parts to a local mechanic who was willing to use them. the sealing surface on the new CV joint was bad, and they started leaking transmission fluid within a couple weeks. Because I supplied the parts, they didn't warranty for a part defect. I ended up paying the labor twice.

Two answer your question, I'd hold off a year or two before replacing the timing belt.
 
#3 ·
The recommended replacement in my 2005 manual is 108 months or 90,000 miles. By my calculations that is 9 years not 6. Of course you realize The 3.3 engine is an interference engine and if the belt breaks it will cause a lot of damage, so you take your chances...or be overly cautious.
 
#4 ·
I would also wait. You can go another 25k miles especially if your engine is not driven in a a severe duty type way or environment. Otherwise early replacement is somewhat of a waste of money.

Plugs can go a long, long time before needing replacement. There is no reason to change them with the timing belt nor does the belt being off lend better plug access so I would just replace them when recommended by the owners manual.
 
#5 ·
Hi,
Thanks for your input. I bought my van used so it did not come with the recommended service interval manual. The local dealers here are saying 6 years/90k miles, whichever comes first for timing belt replacement, and that's what I'd heard online previously, but I guess it's not what the manufacturer actually recommends. Thanks again!
 
#6 ·
Interestingly, they don't suggest a timing belt change on my vehicle. That's out to 120,000 miles.

Go out to Toyota.com. At the bottom of the screen you'll see a button For Owners. Register with Toyota and you'll have access to all the manuals that would have come with your vehicle as well as any Toyota service that was performed on it, instructional videos and a listing of all your dashboard indicators. At least that's what's on my page.